One would think so. Unfortunately they broke my driver handle (the black part not the aluminum trim they put on) and passenger handle when they changed mine from anthracite to aluminum. Going tuesday to have both handles replaced. They also put tiny little dents in the aluminum on the driver and rear passenger handles but that may be my OCD getting the best of me. We'll see what they say at the dealership about that.
However, it is definitely doable and my dealer used one of the cars on the lot as the "donor" for the trim. Get them to do the same.