I didn't think you could get the Luxury Line with sport seats in the US, so if you want sport seats, the only way is Sport line or M-sport - in which case the only choice is M-sport as it looks much better.
Black sapphire exterior with beige interior is classy and nice and Glacier silver with red interior is both sporty and unique. Estoril blue with beige is also nice, but maybe a bit to flashy for you? Mineralgrey is also nice, and goes well with both beige and red.
The F30 looks great in any color; but since you had a silver one, I believe a Black sapphire M-sport with beige interior would be the right one this time