[GTM_Challenge]

Originally Posted by cchrisv

PM for pricing?

Send you a PM with a link to the requested info.

[jsedlak]

Same.

Edit: thanks!

[m5 guy]

Can't wait till they get here next week, the anticipation is killing me!

[spideypm]

I just ordered one!!!!

[the infamous...]

good shit!

[tdizzle]

Pretty good bang for buck. Only concern is installation difficulty/price and warranty issues with BMW.

[spideypm]

Originally Posted by tdizzle

Pretty good bang for buck. Only concern is installation difficulty/price and warranty issues with BMW.

Oops..... is the HFC going to affect my warranty?

[GTM_Challenge]

Originally Posted by spideypm

Oops..... is the HFC going to affect my warranty?

As with any aftermarket part, warranty issues are different dealership to dealership. We haven't had any issues on our shop car, but that's not to say you won't.

There are laws out there to protect the consumer with their rights to aftermarket parts vs. warranty work, but I won't go into them here.

[tdizzle]

Originally Posted by GTM_Challenge

As with any aftermarket part, warranty issues are different dealership to dealership. We haven't had any issues on our shop car, but that's not to say you won't.

There are laws out there to protect the consumer with their rights to aftermarket parts vs. warranty work, but I won't go into them here.

That's the normal line of reasoning. I was curious as to how BMW has reacted in the past to these types of mods. Technically, they have to prove that the issue with your car was caused by the mod (as far as i know) to deny your warranty claim. They can't legally deny your malfunctioning sunroof because you have an intake, but if your car has other issues with the engine, who's to say they wont see a mod and simply say it was the culprit. That's when the lawyers come to play, which few want to bother with (and I think car companies/dealers bank on).

See this alot with the mustang community. As he said, it varies from dealer to dealer also. Some are looking to void any warranty claim if they see a mod while others are much more 'friendly' to modified cars.

[GTM_Challenge]

Originally Posted by tdizzle

Pretty good bang for buck. Only concern is installation difficulty/price and warranty issues with BMW.

Installation is pretty basic. Its much much easier on a lift though.

[RollingLower42]

Originally Posted by jsedlak

Dyno says a pretty consistent 12-20bhp.

AFAIK, because the cat's main purpose is to make the exhaust "cleaner," it doesn't affect the sound nearly as much as the muffler. From what I've seen on YouTube it seems to make the exhaust throatier more than anything else. The goal of removing the cat is to improve the flow of the exhaust. The catless pipe will be louder than the HFC.

Edit: This is from the stage1 thread:


The main difference between Catless and HFC is that the HFC still tries to pass emissions standards. Therefore it sacrifices some performance gains to make it semi-streetable.

So long as the downpipe doesn't throw codes and your exhaust can pass emissions, you should be okay. IF you're caught though... well good luck.

Anyways, if you're going WOT past a cop in an exhaust modified (even the M-Perf exhaust) 335i then you're probably going to get pulled over with or without the modified downpipe.


As always - correct me if I'm wrong. I'm still a novice in this arena.

Just to see if I am on the same page, the catless down pipe (smaller looking downpipe) would be louder but less expensive; while the HFC down pipe (bigger looking DP) which is more money, will be less loud and more likely to pass a SMOG, is this correct?

I guess because it would be not as loud and more likely to pass SMOG, I think I am leaning to the HFC...

[shivaswrath]

Yup...and wiser to go with HFC from a DD/emissions perspective.

[mikew2069]

I ordered the HFC. They're saying its only about a 5hp difference b/t the two which isn't a big deal. I went catless on my last turbo car and have a bad taste in my mouth from that experience so I think this will be perfect.

[jsedlak]

Originally Posted by RollingHard28

Just to see if I am on the same page, the catless down pipe (smaller looking downpipe) would be louder but less expensive; while the HFC down pipe (bigger looking DP) which is more money, will be less loud and more likely to pass a SMOG, is this correct?

I guess because it would be not as loud and more likely to pass SMOG, I think I am leaning to the HFC...

Yeah, it's less expensive, smaller and has more performance because there is nothing in it. The other one they have to add stuff to try and meet the emission standards and that costs time/money.

Unless it's a track car or your car is somehow 8+ (or whatever it is) years old, then just get the HFC.

[NICKTENN]

The price for the HFC seems way too high to me. I bought a set (2 HFC DP) for my 370z for about $100 less from Berk a few years back. What gives?

[jsedlak]

Originally Posted by NICKTENN

The price for the HFC seems way too high to me. I bought a set (2 HFC DP) for my 370z for about $100 less from Berk a few years back. What gives?

It's for a BMW.
And it's the only one on the market.

[mikew2069]

Originally Posted by jsedlak

It's for a BMW.
And it's the only one on the market.

This

[J-boogey]

can you PM me a price full system & catless DP

[GTM_Challenge]

Originally Posted by J-boogey

can you PM me a price full system & catless DP

PM sent

[RollingLower42]

Ordered my Challenge HFC DP this morning. Can't wait for it to come in!

[GTM_Challenge]

Originally Posted by RollingHard28

Ordered my Challenge HFC DP this morning. Can't wait for it to come in!

Thanks for your business, Chris!

[mikew2069]

Originally Posted by RollingHard28

Ordered my Challenge HFC DP this morning. Can't wait for it to come in!

Are you going to run it w/ stock catback? I've been so close to pulling the trigger on the Challenge sport exhaust but I'm nervous it might be too loud for my taste as a DD.