[daveb666]

I bet it's EGR. My march 2017 320d had the exact same issue and no dash lights. Diagnosed as faulty EGR and replaced at around 19000miles. Car now on 35000 miles and doing it again.

[PX3]

Originally Posted by CF-F30

this is what mines doing had first service in december and software update
now have problems again
already had a new egr valve at 12000 miles
65 plate 19000 miles now

Due to the fact it seems intermittent and only when I hover around the 40-50mph mark, it's not bothering me too much at present. Although now I have read this post, when it does occur, it does stand out more.

I guess I will monitor for now and see how it goes. If it get's on my nerves before the next service (Dec), then I will speak to my local garage and see whether it's worth them taking a look.

[psp888]

car in the dealers today, hopefully it will be back to normal.

[PX3]

Originally Posted by psp888

car in the dealers today, hopefully it will be back to normal.

Keep us posted.

I experienced it this morning on a roundabout, it was almost as if someone tried to pull the car backwards momentarily.

[psp888]

EGR valve was tested faulty and replaced, car is back to normal now.

[PX3]

Originally Posted by psp888

EGR valve was tested faulty and replaced, car is back to normal now.

Great, good to hear.

[CF-F30]

Quick update on my car,
Back in to dealers today just had a call from them saying another faulty egr valve.
Thats two now only 19000 miles on clock,whats going on with these?
Not picked it up yet but they say its driving fine now so thats good to hear.
Fingers crossed this one lasts longer as my warranty runs out in December

[Sasquartch]

Originally Posted by CF-F30

Quick update on my car,
Back in to dealers today just had a call from them saying another faulty egr valve.
Thats two now only 19000 miles on clock,whats going on with these?
Not picked it up yet but they say its driving fine now so thats good to hear.
Fingers crossed this one lasts longer as my warranty runs out in December

If you've only done 19k in 2 and a half years maybe a diesel i8snt for you ?

Modern diesels dont like short runs that's for sure

[PX3]

Originally Posted by Sasquartch

If you've only done 19k in 2 and a half years maybe a diesel i8snt for you ?

Modern diesels dont like short runs that's for sure

I am not sure that is the reason!
I have driven an X3 (2.0d) for the last 5/6yrs without any issues and that has only done 38k (62 reg).
Diesel was the only option at the time, as the F25 was not available in petrol.

[PX3]

Originally Posted by CF-F30

Quick update on my car,
Back in to dealers today just had a call from them saying another faulty egr valve.
Thats two now only 19000 miles on clock,whats going on with these?
Not picked it up yet but they say its driving fine now so thats good to hear.
Fingers crossed this one lasts longer as my warranty runs out in December

Doesn't sound good!
I guess I will be looking to extend my warranty when the time comes.