11-17-2013, 06:08 PM | #1 |
Captain
124
Rep 704
Posts
Drives: 2014 328d
Join Date: Aug 2013
Location: Rio Rancho, NM
|
Steering FEEDBACK vs. Steering FEEL
Could someone(s) articulate the difference between steering/road FEEDBACK vs. steering FEEL? These two seem to be closely related yet distinct. Is feedback an aspect of feel, or vice-versa, or neither?
Feedback may be more significant to Driver #1 while feel is more important to Driver #2. And while you're at it, please describe how steering HEFT/HEAVINESS relates to feedback and feel. Feel free to throw in any other major categories that you think help evaluate the steering EXPERIENCE. Inquiring minds (like mine) will be eternally grateful. I think a lot of these disagreements are not really disagreements at all, just people focusing in on different aspects of the steering experience combined with a bit of semantic confusion. |
11-17-2013, 06:25 PM | #2 | |
Law Enforcer
24975
Rep 22,265
Posts
Drives: '22 Chalk Gray Porsche C2S
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: ..in your rearview!!!
|
Quote:
Good question. I'll bite.... ...Where steering/suspension/handling/etc. is concerned, it is my opinion that feel is a component of feedback and the personal sensitivities that drive how you interpret that feedback determines your position(s) on feel (...think about the "too stiff vs too soft" arguments where suspensions are concerned). Steering heft/heaviness is a component of feel rather than feedback, and where heft/heaviness lies on your own personal spectrum of tolerance depends entirely on personal preference (...again, much like suspension tuning). Heavy steering doesn't necessarily equate to responsive feedback and lighter steering doesn't necessarily dictate a lack thereof. In addition, suspension components/geometry and wheel/tire choices all contribute to feedback which then contributes to feel (..example: Add wider wheels/tires on an otherwise stock car and you will immediately notice more tramlining, thus, affecting feedback through the steering wheel, etc.). Even tire pressure can affect feedback, thus feel. It's a bit of an over-simplification to suggest that the rack (..or the technology employed on the rack), alone, is the sole source of feedback and feel. They are all related. More tactile people thirst for more feel (..and as a result, feedback...), but less tactile people don't give it much thought. A really simple example lies within the well designed high-end luxury car. Soft suspension characteristics and steering systems designed with the sole purpose of making you feel like you're riding on a cloud, and insulating you from every road imperfection and/or quibble that the thoroughfare might toss your way. It's not just the rack that accomplishes that. It's the totality of all of those systems working together to produce an end result. The F30 and E90 employ different technologies for the steering rack, but there are variances in the suspensions/track/etc. as well. All of those differences work together to produce an end result that may feel a tad different, but improve the overall abilities of the car by measurable amounts. edit: We can also add brake modulation into the feel/feedback discussion too. Last edited by Sedan_Clan; 11-17-2013 at 06:54 PM.. |
|
Appreciate
0
|
11-18-2013, 08:47 AM | #3 |
Captain
124
Rep 704
Posts
Drives: 2014 328d
Join Date: Aug 2013
Location: Rio Rancho, NM
|
But there seems to be a difference between steering accuracy and steering feel/feedback. Magazine writers can say that the feedback of the f30 is sub-par relative to the E9x but that steering accuracy and feel is better!
|
Appreciate
0
|
11-18-2013, 09:34 AM | #4 |
Lieutenant Colonel
50
Rep 1,730
Posts |
I'll give you the engineering perspective, which necessarily requires some background. I'm still learning about vehicle dynamics myself, but this is what I've absorbed over the last couple months.
First, understand what the steering system is. You are moving the wheel which rotates a column which drives a pinion gear against a steering rack. The rack pushes the tire rods to cause the wheels to rotate about the kingpin axis (which is virtual axis for most multi-arm suspension geometries). There is often compliance (and friction) built into this system to isolate the driver from road/tire noise. Next, understand what the vehicle is doing. When you are moving and apply a steering input, you are generating a lateral force component transferred to the ground via the tire. Depending on the dynamic state of the vehicle (more the suspension) this can vary in complexity. For instance, a 2 wheel vehicle will "lean" into the turn (camber thrust) while a 4 wheel vehicle will twist the pneumatic tire (but can also experience weight transfer and camber thrust etc). From HS physics, we know that a constant turn requires a constant acceleration inwards, so even a constant turn requires continuous steering input (lateral acceleration). Next, what is power steering? Well, due to packaging and gear ratios etc, it might be difficult to steer the wheels without aid. Plus, it is desirable not to require 5 turns each direction to reach steering lock. The power steering system applies a force, usually at the rack, to aid in you in wheel inputs. The requirements for assistance go down as the vehicle speed increases, mainly because small wheel angles result in much larger lateral acceleration. People are very comfortable with Hydraulic Power Steering (HPS) systems, which are belt driven pumps that operate via the accessory belt from the crank shaft. There is some fancy valving done in the pump to control how assist pressure builds as a function of engine driven RPM, similar to the bypass valve on a supercharger. Electric Power Steering (EPS) uses torque sensors + wheel angle sensors fed into an ECU to drive some motors along the rack. The motors have a lot more friction in them (analogous to dampers if you will), hence the problem many have with feedback. EPS improves fuel economy because it is a "on demand" technology, and doesn't constantly sap power from the crank like a HPS pump does. Interestingly, it also allows for the steering ECU to actually turn the wheel *without* your input, enabling features like active park or lane keep etc. OK, lol, now to answer your question. Steering feel, in my opinion, has everything to do with how one perceives the boost curve in their everyday driving. The feel can range from "too light" to "too heavy". Issue with EPS is that the boost is determined by the ECU so may feel "artificial" in certain instances. It must vary as speed changes, and ideally makes parking easier (where you need much higher assist). In my opinion, perceived feel is highly contingent on your own experiences. Do you prefer IPA's or bud light, tube amps or DSP. People love their old sports cars (which had low assist) and now don't like light steering. Steering feedback relates indirectly to how much friction/compliance you have in your steering system. As you are driving hard and turning the vehicle, you will generate lateral force (change torque moments at tire), hit different road surfaces, and change the dynamic state of vehicle accelerate out of turn etc. The question is how much of that gets transmitted back through the steering system. These road surface forces should be transmitted as torques at the wheel (twitches if you will). Expert drivers will know have a good internal feel for how much torque they need to apply depending on what the vehicle is doing. This is learned through much cockpit time, and again is continent on their steering assist system. I am no expert with the electric assist motors, but my guess is that the friction in the motors absorb the forces generated by the road much more than the hydraulic assist valving system. They almost act like dampers. Well that's my $.02, hopefully made some sense and feel free to correct where I'm wrong (which is a sure thing). |
Appreciate
0
|
11-18-2013, 10:08 AM | #5 | |
Major
266
Rep 1,093
Posts |
Quote:
__________________
Has a bad car addiction
|
|
Appreciate
0
|
11-18-2013, 12:37 PM | #6 |
Captain
124
Rep 704
Posts
Drives: 2014 328d
Join Date: Aug 2013
Location: Rio Rancho, NM
|
|
Appreciate
0
|
11-18-2013, 12:42 PM | #7 | |
Law Enforcer
24975
Rep 22,265
Posts
Drives: '22 Chalk Gray Porsche C2S
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: ..in your rearview!!!
|
Quote:
There is! The car should track exactly as intended. Accuracy is pretty self-explanatory actually. |
|
Appreciate
0
|
11-18-2013, 01:25 PM | #8 | |
First Lieutenant
6
Rep 340
Posts |
Quote:
If you track your F30 (especially with an instructor, who is anal about driving lines!), there is no doubt the steering is accurate. I never owned a E9X, so I cannot compare the 2.
__________________
2019 911 GTS
2017 M4 CV 2017 Mini JCW |
|
Appreciate
0
|
11-18-2013, 01:44 PM | #9 | |
Colonel
197
Rep 2,802
Posts |
Quote:
|
|
Appreciate
0
|
11-18-2013, 03:31 PM | #10 |
Captain
124
Rep 704
Posts
Drives: 2014 328d
Join Date: Aug 2013
Location: Rio Rancho, NM
|
Many drivers say that the F30 steering is light and lacks heft/resistance/weight (that's a "bad thing") even though they say "steering feel" is quite good. Are they as confused as I am?
|
Appreciate
0
|
11-18-2013, 03:38 PM | #11 |
Law Enforcer
24975
Rep 22,265
Posts
Drives: '22 Chalk Gray Porsche C2S
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: ..in your rearview!!!
|
I think people need to be more specific when they offer their criticisms. The E9X non-M cars didn't have modes that affected steering and chassis feel; the F3X does. So when a person juxtaposes their feelings about the E9X versus that of the F30/F32, they need to state something like this, "In Comfort mode, the F3X steering feels lighter than the that of the E9X." That's a more accurate statement than just claiming one is lighter than the other. Sport/Sport+ has heft and a nicely weighted steering feel, and arguably feels better than any non-M E9X. The funny thing is that people complained about the light steering in the E9X M3's servotronic rack, but forgave it because it was communicative (..once they adjusted to it). People have really short memories. Normal mode in the M3 wasn't to my tastes, so I always chose the heaviest of the steering modes.
Last edited by Sedan_Clan; 11-18-2013 at 03:49 PM.. |
Appreciate
0
|
11-18-2013, 04:15 PM | #12 | |
Lieutenant General
6659
Rep 15,858
Posts |
Quote:
Seems weight and heft are the big criticism by many. Personally I don't see why it rates so highly, in gauging whether steering is up to the mark. Plus I feel suspension and chassis configurations have a major contribution to steering feedback, as fluidity of the chassis can add or detract to/from steering feel. Isn't steering weight more a personal like or dislike? I've driven Ford, Vauxhall, Jaguar (XF) and other examples with far "lighter" steering than my E91 330d with its heavily weighted HPAS, and the other cars had similar, (or better), steering for feedback and feel. Added steering weight/heft is a preference rather than a mark of good steering, in my opinion. I posted in the other topic that I prefer my 5-series steering in the normal mode, find the sport mode (although nicely weighted) feels damped, compared to the normal setting. I like the more sensitive feel to the steering in normal mode. HighlandPete |
|
Appreciate
0
|
11-18-2013, 04:16 PM | #13 | |
is nonexistent with N/A
21
Rep 1,126
Posts |
Quote:
|
|
Appreciate
0
|
11-18-2013, 04:31 PM | #14 | |
Law Enforcer
24975
Rep 22,265
Posts
Drives: '22 Chalk Gray Porsche C2S
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: ..in your rearview!!!
|
Quote:
Excellent points, and all things that I've mentioned in the other thread... |
|
Appreciate
0
|
11-18-2013, 05:05 PM | #15 | |
Banned
104
Rep 1,715
Posts |
Quote:
I think another issue in this is suspension itself and the effect it has on our perceived "steering feel"...lets also remember in takes some time for our brains to process and analyze data, especially when constantly moving. I have recently driven all 3 cars e92 335 e92 m3 and my f30 335... they are all vastly different from each other...the beauty in the f30 is you can have comfort and absorption, and stiffness all with a very precise steering capability. I just wish there was no roll like the e92's, I think thats the biggest factor in any issues with this car. |
|
Appreciate
0
|
11-18-2013, 10:57 PM | #16 | |
Captain
124
Rep 704
Posts
Drives: 2014 328d
Join Date: Aug 2013
Location: Rio Rancho, NM
|
Quote:
The folks at Dinan deny that Shockware will impact steering feel, but I don't believe it. (I asked a fellow there that very question...maybe he was trying to "dampen" expectations. ) |
|
Appreciate
0
|
11-19-2013, 08:04 AM | #17 | |
Lieutenant Colonel
50
Rep 1,730
Posts |
Quote:
|
|
Appreciate
0
|
11-19-2013, 08:12 AM | #18 | |
Captain
124
Rep 704
Posts
Drives: 2014 328d
Join Date: Aug 2013
Location: Rio Rancho, NM
|
Quote:
Question: Besides lowering CoG, don't stiffer springs by themselves help control body roll? Don't they in effect act as part of a stiffer chassis? |
|
Appreciate
0
|
11-19-2013, 08:24 AM | #19 | |
Lieutenant Colonel
50
Rep 1,730
Posts |
Quote:
The anti-roll bars on the other hand only affect the suspension when one side of the vehicle suspension compresses more than the other. They prevent this by loading up like a spring. Really stiff ARB's are bad if you hit a pot hole, in that they limit the ability of a suspension component to act independently of others. In the limit of stiff ARB's, you have a solid axle. Last edited by drob23; 11-19-2013 at 08:31 AM.. |
|
Appreciate
0
|
11-19-2013, 08:58 AM | #20 |
Captain
124
Rep 704
Posts
Drives: 2014 328d
Join Date: Aug 2013
Location: Rio Rancho, NM
|
But specific to my question, do stiffer springs help to control roll (as part of the chassis response) outside of lowering CoG? I'm aware that struts don't play a "roll" here.
|
Appreciate
0
|
11-19-2013, 09:00 AM | #21 | |
Enlisted Member
0
Rep 40
Posts |
Quote:
But, due to the high friction of electric motors, EPS racks simply don't respond to the road surface as much as HPS systems, which greatly reduces feedback, and also produces poor self-centering, and thus poor on-center feel unless the system is tuned to compensate. Car and Driver described much of this in an excellent article here, and their analysis matches my experience with my Acura's steering: http://www.caranddriver.com/features...n-test-feature In a September 2013 article, C&D measured and described the poor self-centering in the F30's steering relative to the E90's: "The slip angles producing cornering forces at the tire patches create what’s known as aligning torque—essentially, the tire trying to return to straight-ahead running. This aligning torque is fed back through the rack-and-pinion steering gear to the steering wheel. It’s part of the information the driver uses to learn what’s going on where the rubber meets the road. The K&C machine reported that aligning torque is 64 percent lower in the 328i than in the 335i. While the switch to electric power steering may improve mileage, it’s a bummer for Bimmer driving satisfaction." http://blog.caranddriver.com/a-tale-...-so-different/ In normal driving, I actually think the weak self-centering/on-center feel is a bigger issue than nuanced feedback, because it provides a less secure sense of highway tracking. (C&D described this in the above article.) That's where I miss my old Saab's wonderful HPS the most. I haven't driven a huge number of cars with EPS, but only the Ford Focus ST has impressed me with strong on-center feel. Ford has obviously tuned its system to provide high resistance just off-center, which doesn't provide nuanced feedback at all steering angles, but does provide a secure sense of tracking on the highway. On I-95 around Philly, it just felt totally locked in. (If you're interested, Chris Harris describes this aspect of the ST at around 7:00 in this vid: .) |
|
Appreciate
0
|
11-19-2013, 09:15 AM | #22 |
Lieutenant Colonel
50
Rep 1,730
Posts |
Yes, they do. If you took the springs stiffness to infinity you would no longer have any suspension, and the car couldn't roll at all . Stiffer springs reduce body roll.
|
Appreciate
0
|
Post Reply |
Bookmarks |
|
|