09-30-2012, 10:58 PM | #1 |
Enlisted Member
13
Rep 42
Posts |
BMW 328i and ATS 2.0 Battle Again in Direct Comparo by Car and Driver
Featured on BIMMERPOST.com |
09-30-2012, 11:13 PM | #2 |
Lieutenant
63
Rep 595
Posts
Drives: 2014 BMW M235i
Join Date: Aug 2012
Location: Dallas/Ft. Worth, Texas
|
I wonder if the review would have been an easier swing for BMW if the car they tested had the dynamic handling package. The first one I drive with VSS and Adaptive Suspension will be mine so I haven't been able to compare what a difference it makes in the driving feel.
__________________
2014 M235i | Manual | Estoril Blue / Terra | Tech, Premium, HK Audio, & Driver Assist | M Performance Exhaust, Stainless Steel Pedals, Black Kidney Grilles
Euro Delivery Trip Report Last edited by webdither; 10-01-2012 at 12:41 PM.. |
Appreciate
0
|
10-01-2012, 10:25 AM | #5 |
Colonel
341
Rep 2,118
Posts |
Put the Cadillac suspension on the BMW and it sounds like you have a great modern sport sedan. Very disappointing that the Caddy engine is so weak. If GM wants to compete in this class they need to up this part of their game.
|
Appreciate
0
|
10-01-2012, 11:42 AM | #6 |
Major General
1730
Rep 5,110
Posts |
Credit to Cadillac for changing their game since the cars of the '80ies and '90ties. That they actually have a legitimate contender for the 3-series serves them credit.
|
Appreciate
0
|
10-01-2012, 12:05 PM | #7 |
Second Lieutenant
72
Rep 249
Posts |
|
Appreciate
0
|
10-01-2012, 12:15 PM | #8 |
New Member
2
Rep 14
Posts |
Sales of the ATS may be an indicator as to whether BMW Marketing has pushed engineering too far the other way. Apparently they intend the M335i, etc models to cover the enthusiast crowd and the pure ///M models to cover the hard core enthusiasts. Unfortunately, it would seem the general luxury car consumer actually wants a rather dull driving experience. This is so sad!!!
|
Appreciate
0
|
10-01-2012, 12:15 PM | #9 |
Lieutenant
34
Rep 499
Posts |
I feel like the F30 will perform much better in all these comparison tests with better tires... man bmw... losing out on fun factor to a caddy... bavaria must be melting with rage...
__________________
CURRENT - E36 M3 Alpine White | BC Coils | FROMERLY - 2006 Jet Black 330i | Premium Package | ZF AT | LUX 4.0 | Jlevi M3 Front Bumper | CF Mtech spoiler | Gloss Black Grill | Msport wheel | Blacklines | Koni FSD + Eibach Pro-kit | BMS PBX |
Appreciate
0
|
10-01-2012, 12:29 PM | #12 |
Lieutenant
706
Rep 505
Posts |
Well then I guess the general consumer should stay away from BMW. The F30 328i is a blast right out of the box. (At least the Sport model, which I presume over 50% of all models will be.)
__________________
2022 X3 M40i E46 330i ZHP, E90, E89 Z4, F30 320i "Jalopnik Edition", F80 Comp, F80 CS |
Appreciate
0
|
10-01-2012, 12:35 PM | #13 |
Brigadier General
4183
Rep 4,806
Posts
Drives: BMW
Join Date: Mar 2011
Location: Toronto, Ontario
|
I love the ATS for the simple fact that it will really show what direction BMW will choose to go towards. Aside from the ATS' transmission problems (big problem), the ATS is as good if not better in most categories. BMW can't ignore the ATS like they do the CTS because this reaches a bigger market.
Credit Cadillac for keeping with the ATS from the start despite their financial difficulties. IMO despite what people think, the 3-Series, while still an excellent car, is no longer the juggernaut it once was. It hurts just to hear that another car is more fun than the 3-Series. Last edited by TheBingoBalls; 10-01-2012 at 12:43 PM.. |
Appreciate
0
|
10-01-2012, 12:37 PM | #14 |
Lieutenant
706
Rep 505
Posts |
Caddy deserves a lot of credit for the ATS. There are just two things I can't get over. 1) The ATS doesn't look bad at all, but the super geometric Caddy "visual language" really seems like it's lacking any personality to me. Caddy has been using this for a while, I think they are due to update their overall aesthetic. 2) Going into a Caddy dealer sucks. Our nearest Caddy dealer is in an old building, stuck between a Chevy lot and a used car lot. The BMW/Mercedes/Audi dealers around here have really invested in stepping up their dealerships to provide a great all around customer experience. I especially love BMW of Seattle, where my car came from
__________________
2022 X3 M40i E46 330i ZHP, E90, E89 Z4, F30 320i "Jalopnik Edition", F80 Comp, F80 CS |
Appreciate
0
|
10-01-2012, 12:51 PM | #15 | |
Private
39
Rep 52
Posts |
Some thoughts
Quote:
A couple thoughts after watching the video: - It's sad that the 'standard' sport suspension isn't acceptable anymore and enthusiasts would almost feel required to upgrade to an adaptive suspension. I don't like fiddling with a controller and prefer a static suspension, like the one on my e60 550 M-Sport. - (Note: this is for all makes not just BMW) Is electric power steering around for good? I've not read one review where they didn't mention that there was a severe lack of steering feel due to electric assist power steering. Is hydraulic really only reserved for M models now? Artificially weighting it doesn't count as 'feel'. I realize it's due to a fuel savings issue though... maybe my anger should be directed at CAFE standards? - As much as I want to love the ATS, and although I do appreciate their great effort, the ATS needs to be refined just a bit. Maybe when the model is refreshed in a couple years it'll be the e46 clone they want it to be. The interior is too busy, but it's nice to know they can do a great suspension and they didn't do the typical GM thing by downsizing a larger model as this car is quite light. - I've always been a 'biggest engine possible' kind of guy, hence why I have a 550 (M models are too hardcore for me), but the things I hear about the 328 are greater and greater every time. I'd like my next car to be the F31 M-Sport Wagon and initially I was unhappy that they wouldn't offer a 335 Wagon but I'm becoming more and more okay with it. I'll certainly enjoy the fuel savings. |
|
Appreciate
0
|
10-01-2012, 12:51 PM | #16 |
First Lieutenant
146
Rep 399
Posts
Drives: '15 M3
Join Date: May 2012
Location: SF Bay Area, CA
|
Really good review. Informative, well-presented, and unlike Johnny Liebermann's comparo from Motor Trend, Gall's presentation has a clear indication of what they liked, didn't like, and why the BMW won. I haven't been in an ATS, but having sat in the CTS-V, I'd agree that Caddy/GM still don't know how to craft an interior that gives an air of quality and craftsmanship.
It seems like Caddy's drivetrain engineers are closing the gap, but have a LOT of work to do in building a car whose sum is greater than its parts. Here's to hoping they keep trying. |
Appreciate
0
|
10-01-2012, 01:26 PM | #18 | |
Captain
283
Rep 883
Posts |
This should push BMW back on track
__________________
Quote:
|
|
Appreciate
0
|
10-01-2012, 01:39 PM | #19 |
Sarcasm free with all posts.
7
Rep 441
Posts |
sorry, but doesn't look like a close battle in reality. They bitch about handling without getting the "FUN" suspension.
__________________
The best 2013 M sport is owned by me.
|
Appreciate
0
|
10-01-2012, 01:41 PM | #20 |
Second Lieutenant
2
Rep 295
Posts |
Good comparison review. I agree with others - credit to Caddy for building such a car that would be described as "more fun to drive than a 3-series". "More fun to drive" is usually a term used to separate the 3-series from the likes of the C-class, A4, G37, IS350, etc. But I suspect that the ATS' magnetic ride control, LSD, standard Brembo's and chassis give it a slight advantage in terms of performance. Meanwhile it looks/sounds like BMW retains its advantage in engine (though I've read that their 2.0T is a little noisier than the Caddy's) and transmission delivery and package.
From what I've seen and read so far (without driving either one yet) my opinion is that the ATS looks more luxurious but drives more sporty, while the F30 looks more sporty and drives more refined. I like and am attracted to both cars and will seriously consider both before buying next year. Looks are subjective of course, but I'm one of those that likes the looks of both cars. Driving them both back-to-back would be interesting (necessary) and I certainly plan to do that at some point. That and the price would be the deciding factors for me. However, I've always dreamt of owning/driving a BMW 3-series since E36 generation. Kuddos to Caddy for developing this car that will challenge the 3-series. |
Appreciate
0
|
10-01-2012, 01:54 PM | #21 |
Lieutenant Colonel
827
Rep 1,585
Posts |
|
Appreciate
0
|
Post Reply |
Bookmarks |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
|
|