02-15-2016, 10:56 PM | #1 |
Major
987
Rep 1,418
Posts |
xDrive vs. Quattro and the rest
Driving my 340i xDrive in the snow today made me think of a few things. This is my first sports vehicle with AWD and I’m more than pleased with how xDrive has handled the snow we’ve gotten so far in the Northeast.
My thought was how does xDrive as a platform compare against Audi’s Quattro or Subaru’s Symmetrical AWD? I must say a lot of the stability and traction I’m experiencing has to do with the Pirelli Winter Sottozero Serie II’s that I have since even my X5 35i xDrive with all-season tires feels squirrely in this weather. By the way, these Sottozero’s (V-rated version) are amazing… I forget these are snow tires – they perform like a performance all-season. They go, they stop – dry, wet, ice, snow, doesn’t matter, these tires like being used. They’re quiet and they don’t look like knobby snow tires. I haven’t driven on snow tires in over 10 years (last I had were Blizzak which are equally as awesome but floaty) but the Pirelli’s already feel ideal for a sports sedan in the winter. Just hoping these will last longer than 5,000 miles. Anyway, back to xDrive… Do you think its AWD is as good, worse, or better than tried and true Audi and Subaru platforms? What’s the difference? Opinions from drivers that have driven both? Last edited by MomoM3; 02-15-2016 at 11:11 PM.. |
02-15-2016, 11:58 PM | #2 |
Brigadier General
2893
Rep 3,469
Posts |
Not nearly as good as subaru's, have had both. BMW system feels like it has to "turn on" and figure out where to send the torque when you start to slip, which in itself upsets the car some. Tires still make a huge difference and BMWs on true winter tires will still be better than Subaru on performance tires.
|
Appreciate
0
|
02-16-2016, 12:34 AM | #3 |
Major General
4975
Rep 6,238
Posts
Drives: 2018 340i M Sport
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Chicago, Edgewater (via Texas & Tennessee)
iTrader: (0)
Garage List 2018 BMW 340i M Sport [9.38]
2020 BMW M340i xDrive [10.00] 2018 BMW 340i M Sport [8.00] 2006 BMW 330i Sport [4.50] 2004 BMW 330i ZHP [7.25] 2000 BMW 328i [6.00] |
I just wrote a book on them and the internet ate it. I might rewrite it tomorrow.
tl;dr - Audi's thing is fwd architecture cars with awd and Quattro is more sporty than xDrive. BMW's thing is rwd, motor behind the front axle, sporty, and xDrive is more utilitarian. Subaru's thing is pretty much purely utilitarian. Last edited by tturedraider; 02-16-2016 at 12:50 AM.. |
Appreciate
0
|
02-16-2016, 12:44 AM | #4 | |
Major General
4975
Rep 6,238
Posts
Drives: 2018 340i M Sport
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Chicago, Edgewater (via Texas & Tennessee)
iTrader: (0)
Garage List 2018 BMW 340i M Sport [9.38]
2020 BMW M340i xDrive [10.00] 2018 BMW 340i M Sport [8.00] 2006 BMW 330i Sport [4.50] 2004 BMW 330i ZHP [7.25] 2000 BMW 328i [6.00] |
Quote:
Subaru has the ability to direct torque to individual wheels, I think using the awd system combined with the brake system based on what their website says. Their torque split is generally either 50:50 or 45:55, depending on the model. |
|
Appreciate
0
|
02-16-2016, 12:55 AM | #5 |
Dust Bunny
98
Rep 189
Posts |
Between my F31 and Q5, honestly in regular day to day drives the differences are practically imperceptible to me. Tires are far more important but assuming they're the same I personally feel quattro is a bit more competent, a bit more sure footed but also a bit more muted. You get the sense that the car is telling you "don't worry I got this sorted" but doesn't tell you what it's doing. BMW's system is probably a bit less high-tech but as a result I feel like it's a bit more communicative.
|
Appreciate
0
|
02-16-2016, 01:17 AM | #6 |
Private First Class
45
Rep 132
Posts |
Audi has several different system all designated "Quattro." They are not all equal, not at all. To compare xDrive to Quattro you'd need to be more specific. Having said that, in my opinion the rubber makes a more significant contribution to traction than which particular manufacture's system you're using.
I have PSS on my car. On snow and ice, the Quattro system will do very little for me.
__________________
2014 S4
|
Appreciate
0
|
02-16-2016, 02:42 AM | #7 |
Brigadier General
1433
Rep 4,724
Posts |
It's the tires. I have them too and love them.
__________________
Current: 2021 M340i xDrive
Previous: '18 340i xDrive; '15 335 xDrive; '14 435i xDrive; '09 335 E92 xDrive |
Appreciate
0
|
02-16-2016, 05:29 AM | #8 |
Colonel
432
Rep 2,527
Posts |
A4 quattro models are longitudinal engine setups (same as bmw) and torsen awd. All four wheels are always powered in the audi vs on the bmw defaulting to RWD until it senses a slip. Quattro feels way more planted for me while xdrive is a bit more fun. On an unplowed road with nannies off the audi will tend to drift if I crank the steering wheel and stomp the gas while the bmw will want to turn the tail around. That being said both cars driven sensibly are very safe and get you through pretty much anything.
|
Appreciate
1
Operator Mo64.50 |
02-16-2016, 08:04 AM | #9 |
Lieutenant General
8243
Rep 16,080
Posts |
Winters will work better than all seasons, but my XDrive with all seasons is still far superior to any of the RWD or FWD cars I've had shod with winters. I might be concerned with the comparative abilities of Audi and Subaru if I plowed with my car, or drove across the frozen tundra, or did Pikes Peak mid-winter, but I don't.
|
Appreciate
2
|
02-16-2016, 08:06 AM | #10 | |
Brigadier General
2893
Rep 3,469
Posts |
Quote:
|
|
Appreciate
0
|
02-16-2016, 08:26 AM | #11 | |
Brigadier General
1610
Rep 3,947
Posts |
Quote:
AWD cars: 2008 Subaru Legacy GT with Continental ExtremeContact DWS 2016 BMW X3 35i with stock All Season RFT tires RWD: 2014 335i M Sport RWD with Michelin X-Ice Xi3 The RWD + studless winter tire outperforms all my AWD + all season cars. There's really no comparison. The Subaru and the X3 are a bit better in terms of deep snow but it's not like a sedan is going to go through deep snow like a 4wd pickup truck. You can even argue that Subaru's AWD setup is better for snow/ice than the BMW xDrive since it is a locked 45:55 split front and rear axles. It also has a viscous limited slip rear differential compared to the BMW's open differential. |
|
Appreciate
0
|
02-16-2016, 09:05 AM | #12 | ||
Major General
4975
Rep 6,238
Posts
Drives: 2018 340i M Sport
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Chicago, Edgewater (via Texas & Tennessee)
iTrader: (0)
Garage List 2018 BMW 340i M Sport [9.38]
2020 BMW M340i xDrive [10.00] 2018 BMW 340i M Sport [8.00] 2006 BMW 330i Sport [4.50] 2004 BMW 330i ZHP [7.25] 2000 BMW 328i [6.00] |
Quote:
Quote:
|
||
Appreciate
0
|
02-16-2016, 09:09 AM | #13 |
Major General
4975
Rep 6,238
Posts
Drives: 2018 340i M Sport
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Chicago, Edgewater (via Texas & Tennessee)
iTrader: (0)
Garage List 2018 BMW 340i M Sport [9.38]
2020 BMW M340i xDrive [10.00] 2018 BMW 340i M Sport [8.00] 2006 BMW 330i Sport [4.50] 2004 BMW 330i ZHP [7.25] 2000 BMW 328i [6.00] |
Per CNET, Subaru uses at least four different versions of Symmetrical AWD.
http://www.cnet.com/roadshow/news/no...created-equal/ |
Appreciate
0
|
02-16-2016, 09:53 AM | #14 | |
Curmudgeon and Pedant
690
Rep 3,489
Posts |
Quote:
All that is being said is ok. In theory, the Audi and Subaru systems are theoretically "better", since they never waste energy in the braking system like BMW's ADB/electronic diff. However, the amount used ("wasted") is so slight - especially where you should be off-throttle anyway - that it's a bit of a nonsensical argument. And since all systems now have DSC that "wastes" energy it doesn't matter much in any case. There are plenty of videos out there comparing the three cars. Everyone wins. And in the final analysis: "Having AWD/4WD just means you get stuck further into the woods/down the road." |
|
Appreciate
0
|
02-16-2016, 10:09 AM | #15 |
Major General
4516
Rep 8,942
Posts |
Really just depends on what you want. If you want something that is more RWD focused and acts as such the xdrive is better. "Real Quattro" Audis are great, the Haldex FWD stuff is good for fuel economy but you're driving a FWD car most of the time. Benzes are all different too. CLA 4matic is FWD based whereas the C450 I just drove is 33/67. So as others have mentioned it's not as easy to lump a particular brand all together. All of them have pros and cons.
__________________
2022 Macan S
2016 F31 328i xDrive Sport Wagon 2006 E46 330ci ZHP Convertible |
Appreciate
1
|
02-16-2016, 10:13 AM | #16 |
I'll Kung Fu Panda your ass
106
Rep 2,100
Posts |
I just go weeeeeeeeeee....XDrive & Michelin X-Ice Xi3 on....just have fun. No issues yesterday as I was driving...just the damn traffic..
__________________
'16 F30 340 XDrive - AW-Lighting & Track Packages. The FIRST drive was awesome....
|
Appreciate
1
|
02-16-2016, 10:49 AM | #17 |
Lieutenant Colonel
813
Rep 1,986
Posts
Drives: 2014 335i xdrive, 2014 X5 3.5d
Join Date: Mar 2014
Location: Owen sound, Ontario, canada
|
I live in snow belt part of the province and have both Subaru and bimmer Xdrive so I use them on a daily basis. Xdrive is good when there a bit of snow and hold its own good, Subaru on the other hand doesn't care how much snow there is. It just goes thru everything. I've tried making Subie slide but was never successful. There's something to be said about AWD all the time, it always feels safe and needless o say, when weather gets really bad, it's Subie that we take to drive...
|
Appreciate
1
Operator Mo64.50 |
02-16-2016, 01:55 PM | #18 | |
Enlisted Member
8
Rep 33
Posts |
Quote:
|
|
Appreciate
0
|
02-16-2016, 02:03 PM | #19 |
Lieutenant General
8243
Rep 16,080
Posts |
|
Appreciate
0
|
02-16-2016, 02:34 PM | #20 |
First Lieutenant
85
Rep 381
Posts |
In rankings of AWD systems that I've used I'll rate them as this:
Subaru-BMW-Audi/MBZ Most Quattro vehicles I've seen have had warranty repairs on the AWD. Granted the BMWs have some transfer case issues too, my STI had 0 AWD problems with 525whp. |
Appreciate
0
|
02-16-2016, 02:36 PM | #21 |
Major
707
Rep 1,170
Posts |
As others have noted most manufacturers have several different 4wd/AWD systems offered so an apple to apple comparison is difficult, I think Jeep currently has 13 different systems. I'm waiting on a 340i xDrive so I can't comment on it but I'm in a Subaru now, before that always had 4x4. As far as on highway winter driving my Suby with Auto Trans is better than my Jeep with Quadratrac and the Jeep was better than the "regular" 4x4 SUV's and Pick-ups that came before it. Having said that put the wrong tires on any of them and you are asking for trouble. Here is some information that helped me decide to give the BMW system a try. http://www.cnet.com/roadshow/news/a-...ve-technology/
|
Appreciate
0
|
02-16-2016, 02:45 PM | #22 |
Lieutenant Colonel
813
Rep 1,986
Posts
Drives: 2014 335i xdrive, 2014 X5 3.5d
Join Date: Mar 2014
Location: Owen sound, Ontario, canada
|
Now only if Subaru could design better interiors...
|
Appreciate
1
Operator Mo64.50 |
Post Reply |
Bookmarks |
Tags |
awd, quattro, subaru, xdrive |
|
|